Frodo just has that retarded smile that just pisses me off in LOTR. And he's always like "O Sam"...
What Tolkien books have you read?
| Author | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 Putrid Wind |
Re: Re: tolkien books | ||
|
Posts: 1372 (06/04/06 14:37) Euro Dance DJ |
|
||
|
deniz tek |
> Re: Re: tolkien books | ||
|
Posts: 29 (06/04/06 18:39) Uruk-Hai |
yea Frodo is such a little baby in the movies.And Sean astin is the worst castmember I feel.But as someone said,Sean Bean as Boromir is really great-better than in the books-in the books he's a plot device to move the story in certain ways-sean bean made him a great character.
and I hated all the internal conflict added to characters that didn't need it(aragorn for instance)I think the external conflict was enough FFS! |
||
|
Putrid Wind |
Re: > Re: Re: tolkien books | ||
|
Posts: 1372 (06/04/06 21:32) Euro Dance DJ |
I agree, Sean Bean is overall one of my favorite actors and he did a great job.
As to the internal conflicts they weren't all too annoying, I just though Arwen and Aragorns relationship was emphasized a little too much. But still they did a wonderful job translating the book into a movie. |
||
|
Lord Curufinwe |
Re: > Re: Re: tolkien books | ||
|
Yes. Boromir was my favorite role in the movie. Though he has only a short part, its very well done. You can see, how he is just a noble man, who just cant resist the ring. Which could have happened to anyone.
 |
|||
|
Nienna |
Re: > Re: Re: tolkien books | ||
|
Posts: 31 (06/08/06 10:55) Uruk-Hai |
I think Denethor plays a great role as well. It is a secondary character in the movie, but I love the way it is played.
Cheers. |
||
|
Putrid Wind |
Re: > Re: Re: tolkien books | ||
|
Posts: 1372 (06/08/06 15:10) Euro Dance DJ |
Yes John Noble does indeed play the role masterfully. He is completely different in the behind the scenes interviews.
Also has anyone seen the extended version of the Two Towers? (I ask this because there is a very good scene at Osgiliath between Boromir and Denethor that didn't make the theatrical version) |
||
|
Evilbone |
Re: > Re: Re: tolkien books | ||
|
Posts: 609 (06/09/06 00:08) Valarauko |
Yeah I have the extended trilogy but I haven't watched it in the last few months.
|
||
|
Nienna |
Re: > Re: Re: tolkien books | ||
|
Posts: 31 (06/09/06 03:18) Uruk-Hai |
Yes, I have watched the extended trilogy as well and I remember that there was as scene with Boromir and Denethor which makes the argument more consistent.
|
||
|
Lord Curufinwe |
Re: > Re: Re: tolkien books | ||
|
Yes, that is a nice scene, where you can see the honour and the leadership of Boromir
|
|||
|
Macabre Vultur |
Re: tolkien books | ||
|
Posts: 30 (06/10/06 12:19) Uruk-Hai |
About books... I've read Hobbit, Lotr and Silmarillion... I was also trying to read "Morgoth's ring"(I know it's uncorrect title...but at russian it was translated as "Kol'tso Morgota")
I think, of all these books my favourite is Lotr... Silmarillion is also interesting, but I became involved with so many names...  It's a funny thing what my best friend has read Lotr about five or six times, but it's impossible for me....  About movie... I just want to say E. Wood is suxxx... He looks like deeds and events of Lotr are not about him...I read the book after the movie, but I couldn't imagine Elijah as Frodo...I wonder who takes him for this role... And also I dislike in the movie Galadriel and Elrond... I guess it's a three the worst roles in the movie.... P.S. And I just don't like the actor which played Eomer... My favourite was Gimli(of course...John Rhys-Davis as Gimli just perfect, imo), Gandalf, Bilbo. Aragorn, Sam and Theoden also good... Eowyn and Saruman...hmm...Not bad, but they could be better, I think. But much of all I like Nazguls... Perfect roles, perfect characters...
|
||
|
Lord Curufinwe |
Re: tolkien books | ||
|
Nienna |
Re: tolkien books | ||
|
Posts: 31 (06/11/06 09:11) Uruk-Hai |
B***dy hell... No comments...
|
||
|
Putrid Wind |
Re: tolkien books | ||
|
Posts: 1372 (06/11/06 09:56) Euro Dance DJ |
 roflmao |
||
|
Gorbag |
Re: tolkien books | ||
|
Posts: 537 (06/11/06 10:10) Orc Chieftain |
Hehehe, I've seen this some months ago on albinoblacksheep.com
Cool.  |
||
|
Angbandwolf |
Re: tolkien books | ||
|
Posts: 58 (06/11/06 11:40) Black Numenorean |
me too. nice video.
|
||
|
Evilbone |
Re: tolkien books | ||
|
Posts: 609 (06/11/06 14:51) Valarauko |
Yeah always funny to watch
|
||
|
Gorbag |
Re: tolkien books | ||
|
Posts: 537 (06/11/06 15:06) Orc Chieftain |
|
||
|
Evilbone |
Re: tolkien books | ||
|
Posts: 609 (06/12/06 00:57) Valarauko |
wtf? O_o
lol that was crazy |
||
|
Lord Curufinwe |
Re: tolkien books | ||
|
hahaha that is great
|
|||
|
EndlessHelga |
Re: tolkien books | ||
|
Posts: 64 (06/12/06 10:49) Black Numenorean |
ha-ha
nice  You lose your routineCause I've found my path. Sandra Nasic .. |
||
